Home Site Content Official TMC Reviews
Official TMC Reviews > Wed, 1-30-08

This Will Destroy You - This Will Destroy You

This Will Destroy You - This Will Destroy You
Author review
Musicianship
70%70%70%
3.5
Production
90%90%90%
4.5
Originality
80%80%80%
4.0
Average 80%

Musicianship
80%80%80%
4.0
Production
90%90%90%
4.5
Originality
80%80%80%
4.0
1 user rated 83% average
This Will Destroy You
This Will Destroy You

Fortunately/Unfortunately, they couldn't destroy a fly.


Post-rock is beginning to become stale. Of course, other music websites (cough) have declared the genre "dead" for a few years now, but now it's slowly starting to happen. Due to the generalization of the genre that the chord progressions are easy, the music slow and plodding, and without the need for lyrics, post-rock bands have become like the sands of the Earth. This Will Destroy You's debut EP, Young Mountain, was a fine collection of songs to be sure, but as by-the-numbers as countless other bands working today.

With their self-titled first official full-length album, This Will Destroy You have somewhat miraculously carved their own name out of a genre plagued with pale imitators. "A Three-Legged Workhorse" begins with a gentle feedback noise, slowly gaining intensity until an almost Massive Attack-esque electronic beat brings in the classic "post-rock" guitar, crescendoing into a beautiful (though typical) distorted rock-out. By-the-numbers, but with a few surprises along the way.

Next comes "Villa Del Refugio", and here's where listeners not up for this particular journey will be weeded out. A purely ambient 7-minute piece of delicately pulsing electronics, it's hauntingly gorgeous. Explosions of the Sky and Mono fan boys will become impatient, however, as they sit and wait for a release that isn't going to happen. "Threads" follows with a fairly standard Explosions-style build up, only to surprise us with a further blast of energy over two-thirds into the song. It has become clear that where most post-rock bands have become about the destination, or the "release", This Will Destroy You focus their efforts into the long and winding road to get there.

After the quick "Leather Wings", which has no big release at all, we find "The Mighty Rio Grande", the album's longest song. After 5 minutes of an expertly gradual build-up, it simply drops out back into ambient electronics. Once the guitar and drums are slowly re-instated, a second build-up slowly begins, and more intensely than before - but after 11 minutes, the song ends with no true "big moment".

The electronic beats return in "They Move On Tracks Of Never-Ending Light " for seven minutes of wandering beauty that doesn't even bother to build or crescendo at all. That is finally accomplished in the album closer, "Burial On The Presidio Banks". What makes this track such a satisfying ending is the fact that it's the only full-fledged bombastic rock-out after the first track. The album carries an elegant, graceful arc; starting and ending big, and holding an emotional tale in between. Most post-rock bands (such as Explosions) show their big guns right out of the gate, and keep it going throughout the length of the album. What This Will Destroy You have done is made an album-long crescendo, and for those with plenty of patience, the experience is truly rewarding.

This Will Destroy You don't rock out frequently enough to become the next Explosions In The Sky, but with this accomplished debut album they will win over many fans of ambient and minimalist music; not that they play either genre, but that they loosely play "post-rock" with the mind-frame of ambient composers. These songs are expertly crafted and perfectly produced, and while it may not be completely original, for those who've been choked up lately it's a long deep breath of fresh air.

Grade: B

http://www.myspace.com/thiswilldestroyyou

1. A Three-Legged Workhorse
2. Villa Del Refugio
3. Threads
4. Leather Wings
5. The Mighty Rio Grande
6. They Move On Tracks Of Never-Ending Light
7. Burial On The Presidio Banks
Submitted by Mike
Comment
 
Brodband
Senior Member
Brodband is offline
 
Brodband's Avatar
Join Date: Jul 07
Location: Seattle
Posts: 735
#2 (Permalink) Thu, 1-31-08, 11:53 PM Old
 
I've seen some people refer to them as the next Explosions In The Sky or Mogwai even after Young Mountains came out and it's listed as #2 album of 2008 so far on Rate Your Music, so it'll be interesting to see if that all sticks and if they truly start to build a real fanbase and gain any similar sort of wide recognition. I do think everyone and their mom was doing post-rock a few years ago and that's sort of what killed it in that none of them would even up standing out from another, all being very standard, and there wouldn't be much of a lasting impression. I found something special with the self-titled though and for it to be an above average release even though they didn't take those big moments to the extreme here. In this case, the journey is much more interesting than the destination and if you keep those ideas and you're willing to take part in it, it'll leave post-rock fans very satisfied. Very nice review Mike.
 
Send a message via Yahoo to Brodband
Reply With Quote
Mike
Reviewer
Mike is offline
 
Mike's Avatar
Join Date: Apr 07
Location: Toronto
Posts: 304
#3 (Permalink) Fri, 2-1-08, 9:45 AM Old
 
^ Unfortunately their #2 spot on RYM will NOT last long. The rating itself is only around 3.58 currently, and that's not nearly enough to get you into the top 100 at the end of the year. Although, that's how I heard of them in the first place - a couple weeks ago they were number one of 2008 so I had to check it out.
 
Reply With Quote
Charlie
Moderator
Charlie is offline
 
Charlie's Avatar
Join Date: Mar 07
Location: Nashville
Posts: 2,867
#4 (Permalink) Fri, 2-1-08, 11:53 AM Old
 
Excellent review! Honestly I haven't checked it out at all yet, and this gives me a little push to.
 
Send a message via AIM to Charlie
Reply With Quote
Enhanced84
Senior Member
Enhanced84 is offline
 
Enhanced84's Avatar
Join Date: Jun 07
Posts: 380
#5 (Permalink) Sat, 2-2-08, 2:10 AM Old
 
Nice review. I've been getting into more post-rock recently and remember hearing their EP when it came out and liking it a lot, so this will go on my long list of albums I have to hear this winter. I'll probably have plenty of time to do so as well before the warmth sets in and now's the best time to listen to this type of music.
 
Reply With Quote
Comment


Review Tools Search this Review
Search this Review:

Advanced Search

Posting Rules
You may not post new reviews
You may not post comments
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Copyright ©2007 TheMilkCarton.com vBulletin, Copyright ©2000 - 2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Powered by vBadvanced CMPS v3.0 RC2